Idol Chit-Chat
This is your place to discuss all things "American Idol." The performances, the judges, the past contestants — it’s all right here.

Thursday, March 15, 2012

Top 12 Results: The Bottom Three Are...

8:46 We’re back…Heejun, Erika and Hollie…Hollie…Jimmy says he gives Hollie straight As, but he thought she was dressed too old…Heejun…Jimmy says he’s boxed himself in and needs to find some tempo…Erika…Jimmy says Erika fell into the oversinging trap. Jimmy defends his “catchy, jerky arrangement”…Dim the lights…Hollie…safe…I still think it’s Erika in the bottom. Heejun is popular…Erika…Bottom three…Heejun is stunned…The judges don’t look happy…Phillip gives Heejun a big hug…JLo says she is not happy…Steven agrees. Sticks up for Elise…Randy says it’s very strange…One to safety…It’s Elise! The judges are relieved…That leaves Shannon and Erika. I really thought Shannon was more popular than that…After the break…

Erika gave the better performance, but she messed with a popular song, so I think it’s her. The judges love her, but they won’t save her. They’ll save it for their other faves…