Idol Chit-Chat
This is your place to discuss all things "American Idol." The performances, the judges, the past contestants — it’s all right here.

Thursday, March 8, 2012

Top 13 Results: More Twists and Turns

8:32 We’re back…Ryan is back with the contestants…Erika, Shannon and Skylar. Got to believe it’s Shannon…Erika…Jimmy says she wasn’t made for this song but did a really believable job. He says she has a presentation problem. I think she looked so effortless singing that…Jimmy says the nerves got to Shannon and she needs a lot more experience…Shannon said in her backstage video that she only cracked one note. I think it was more than that…Skylar…Jimmy disagrees with JLo and says he likes nasal…

8:35 Dim the lights…Erika…Bottom three. Remember that’s bottom three GIRLS…Shannon and Skylar…Safe is…Skylar. Shannon is the third of the bottom three girls. No surprise there…The bottom three girls are Erika, Shannon and Elise…

8:36 The rest of the guys…Joshua…Jimmy says he is concerned people will get bored of his voice and that he’s worried about him. ‘kay…Deandre…Jimmy says he was a pleasant surprise…Phillip…You just are. I like that…Jimmy says he’s a great musician and that he really knows who he is. Jimmy is concerned the girls will outshine him in the weeks to come. Clearly he’s planning on him sticking around…Jeremy…Jimmy says Stevie ballads are custom made for him and he didn’t perform. Jimmy says he’s going to go home. I don’t agree with that…

8:40 Dim the lights…Phillip is safe…Jeremy…Bottom three. Remember, bottom three GUYS…Deandre and Joshua…Deandre is safe. Uh-oh. Did Joshua get bit by going first?...No, he didn’t, because Ryan pulls a classic move and tells Erika and Joshua are safe. That leaves Jermaine and Jeremy and Elise and Shannon. I still say it’s Elise. And I’ll go with Jermaine. The problem with this twist is that whoever the bottom girl or guy is does not mean they are in the bottom two overall. And they could still go home. THAT’S not fair…