Top 12 Girls: Chelsea Makes a Bad Choice

Has it really been five years since a girl won this thing? Wow…

Let’s see what this year’s crop can do…

Chelsea Sorrell, “Cowboy Cassanova”: 14

This was a terrible song choice. You should never pick a Carrie Underwood song as your very first live performance song (And yes, that means I agree with Randy.). And I thought it was a little too karaoke.