Top 13 Guys: What Show Am I Watching?

DeAndre Brackensick, “Reasons”: 15

We learned another “Idol” lesson tonight. Don’t start out your very first live performance on national TV with a falsetto. Too much room for error. And DeAndre had plenty of error. It was incredibly shaky. He worked some of it out, but I don’t think he ever overcame that beginning, no matter what the judges thought. In fact, I’m not really sure what they were listening to…

And someone is going to have to tell Steven to stop talking when JLo is supposed to…

After the break, Colton Dixon…

I’m starting to think I’m not watching the same show as everyone else…