Top 12 Girls: Haley Butchers My Fave

Haley Johnson, “Sweet Dreams”: 11

I was so psyched when Nigel tweeted that Haley was doing Annie Lennox, but that was ATROCIOUS! Why didn’t she just sing the melody? You butcher my beloved Annie Lennox, you will feel my wrath!

And kudos to Randy for having the guts to come out and say it was a nightmare. Mad props, dawg!