Top 12: Haley Confuses Us All With a Bad Choice

Haley Reinhart, “I’m Your Baby Tonight”: 14
The vocals weren’t so bad, but it was just a terrible choice. Her movements around the stage were so stilted. But the bluesy ending was great and I agree with Steven. That’s what she should do. But I think she’s in real trouble.

How cool was that button her family member was wearing with the digital LED sign running on it?

And I’m with Ryan. That was terribly uncomfortable to hear Jennifer telling her how gorgeous she looked when she clearly had lipstick all over her chin…