Simon sticks up for a bad performance...

Haley Scarnato, “Missing You”: 10
Who decided to make this song so low? She sounded better with Diana. I take back what I said about Brandon. That was the biggest choke I’ve ever heard on the “Idol” stage. And Haley really should’ve just kept her mouth shut about that whole “worst performance ever” stuff. Simon was clearly trying to rally support for her. I’m betting he’s hoping that by convincing America she was good, he can get rid of Sanjaya.