Idol Chit-Chat
This is your place to discuss all things "American Idol." The performances, the judges, the past contestants — it’s all right here.

Wednesday, February 22, 2012

The Green Mile Part 1: More Tough Cuts...

We’re back…

Next up, Neco Starr…We haven’t seen much from him lately, so I’m not sure…Final Performance: “The Lady In My Life.” I thought it sounded a little weak…JLo gives the “so many good singers, we’re spoiled” speech…Not in…JLo says he needs a little more time to figure out who he is. He was pretty cold about it…

Clayton Farhat out…

River St. James…out…He takes it calmly…

Caleb Johnson out…He forgot the words during his final performance…Apparently they didn’t let him start the song over. That was cold…

#Tylerism Alert: Caleb: Can I get some water: Steven: You’re surrounded by it.

Elise Testone…Got to believe she’s in…Recap of her…Final Performance: “This Is a Man’s World”…Oh yeah, she’s got to be in…Randy gives the “so blessed with singers” speech…She’s in…Randy says she’s one of the best singers they’ve seen…

I’ve got a bad feeling about Phil Phillips. The final performance is not the time to be taking risks…

After the break…