Top 12 Results Show: And the Person Going Home Is...

8:53 We’re back…Ryan reminds everyone how they can donate to the Red Cross…Naima, Karen and Haley centerstage. They are not holding hands…One is safe and that is…Naima is safe. Predicted that one too…I don’t really want to see Haley go, but I want to be right…It’s Karen! Haley is safe!...Haley doesn’t seem to get a lot of love from her fellow Idols…

8:55 Karen sings “Hero” for the judges, but you know they’re not going to use the save this early—especially when she’s given two weak performances in a row…JLo and Randy deliberate…JLo and Steven deliberate…JLo looks very sad…This song was so much better the first time she did it. I don’t know what’s happened to her, but she’s totally lost her voice…

8:57 Casey cheers her on, but he’s got to know she’s going home…Karen starts to lose it a little…Karen starts to beg a little…But you can tell from JLo that’s she’s going home…Karen starts to beg a lot…Ryan asks Randy and he said it’s not unanimous that they’re not going to use the save. JLo scoots back from the table a little. Did she want to use the save? That would have been a mistake…

8:58 Goodbye video starts with her mom…They are so misusing David’s song. It never comes in at the right point…Karen starts crying and the judges actually come out of their seats to hug her. That’s a first…The Idols start coming over…Ryan doesn’t even say goodbye. We only hear some of the conversation going on between the judges and Idols. JLo is seriously talking up Naima. Something about Marc is coming over. This is the most the judges have ever socialized with the contestants…

9:00 And we’re out…

Final thoughts in a moment…