Top 9 Results Take Two: Did America Get It Right?

So did America get it right? Yes I believe they did. Although Siobhan should be arrested for what she did to “Suspicious Minds” last night, she probably didn’t deserve to go home before Katie. And even though Aaron was probably worse than Katie this week, he’s been better in the long run and probably deserved to stay more.

Sadly for Katie, she probably would’ve nailed an inspirational song next week…

Since I was so psyched about it I should mention that no, there was no mention of Ryan’s behavior whatsoever tonight—even by Simon. I’m guessing they all just wanted to move on. And yes, Ryan did behave himself a little more tonight, only showing occasional moments of loopiness…much to my chagrin…

Next week, it’s the “Idol Gives Back” extravaganza. No word on whether a contestant will actually be eliminated or if they’ll all be spared like during season six. I guess that’s a surprise.

While we ponder that, let me know your thoughts. Did the right people go home? Post a comment to get the discussion started…