The Judges and I Completely Disagree Over Siobhan

Siobhan Magnus, “Any Man of Mine”: 12
This is the song that tripped up Mandisa, but her performance was better than this one. She dragged the tempo—as evidenced by Shania finding it hard to clap along. She made the whole thing sound like a pageant song. And she didn’t inject any attitude into it at all.

So why is it that she does one slightly in key scream and the judges completely forget the mess that came before it?

Final thoughts in a moment…