Top 12 Guys: Did I Just Agree With Randy?!
Robbie Rosen, “In the Arms of the Angels”: 16
Robbie has a gorgeous voice, but I thought this one just sounded off. It actually took me a while to recognize what the song even was. The rhythm was off, the notes were off, and he was just off. I think it could have been a good choice if he had stuck closer to the original. I can’t believe I’m about to say this, but I’m with Randy on this one…