Idol Chit-Chat
This is your place to discuss all things "American Idol." The performances, the judges, the past contestants — it’s all right here.

Wednesday, April 30, 2008

And the person going home tonight is...

9:55 We’re back…Ryan calls Syesha and Brooke back to the stage…He still doesn’t say they’re the bottom two…Syesha grabs her throat. She‘s probably preparing to sing…It’s…Brooke…YES!!!…She starts crying almost before Ryan gets her name out. She‘s not at all surprised…Goodbye video…So was Syesha the second-lowest vote getter or was that producer manipulated?…Man, do I hate that goodbye song…

9:58 Brooke asks Ryan if she can say thank you and she does--quickly for a change…The Idols join her as she sings “I Am I Cried“…Paula appears to be willing Brooke to sing…Syesha is in tears and looks a little sick…David C. pushes Brooke in the back for some reason. Not sure what that was about. I guess he was trying to keep her on the stage…Brooke says thank you and then turns around and walks to the back of the stage crying…Ryan follows her and puts his hand on her shoulder…

10:00 And we’re out…